D/s without punishment
I've recently read The Heart of Dominance A Guide to Practicing Consensual Dominance by Anton Fulmen. I think it's meant as a deep, but introductory text into the theory of D/s, and I thought it might be good to use that as a trigger of some sort to re-visit my own views, feelings and experiences from various angles given I haven't done so for many years. It's a very good read, in my opinion. It did make me intellectually conscious about (and remind/reinforce) aspects of D/s that I only practiced on a more subconscious, intuitive level before.
While reading about positive and negative reinforcement, punishments and rewards it occurred to me that I once had a D/s relationship with a submissive partner whom I do not recall to have needed to punish even once. Initially I thought I might have forgotten something and tried to remember more of what we did back in the day. Very interesting! As the opportunity presented itself, I asked her about it, and she agreed: She also didn't remember any such instance.
And no, this doesn't mean what we had was no D/s. It very much was, and even now in 20 years of hindsight we both consider it a very well, possibly the best working D/s dynamic that we experienced.
This is definitely a thought to explore further. My initial take is that it merely shows that I'm not a sadist and she was not masochistic. She was very eager to please me, and I was eager to be pleased. I'd say it was a loop of her devotion to whatever kinky rules and demands I come up with, and my sincere appreciation for that devotion to meet my needs and wishes, which she recognized and the circle started again.
To be fair, when I said no punishment I mostly meant the stereotypical punishments involving pain, like spankings. That didn't happen. I suppose there would have been inherently other/milder forms of negative reinforcement, such as expressing my disapproval of something that may have been done in a better way. I don't recall explicit situations for that, but I know that's very well in my nature. So I don't think we're talking about a lack of consequence here. Both positive and negative reinforcement existed.
I'll post an update if more memories, discoveries or conclusions about this topic should arise. One thing that keeps puzzling me is why I never consciously realized this fact before. I did of course notice and recognize that this particular D/s dynamic worked extremely well compared to others. But it seems I embarrassingly never noticed one of the key aspects: The need for no (painful) punishments.
At least one question remains open: Is the lack for need of (painful) punishments merely a sign of how good our D/s needs matched?
Or is it the other way around: As she never was overchallenged by my requests, and extremely devoted to fulfill them, we never had to reach a point where punishment was needed. Having a working dynamic without painful punishments might then have become what turned it into such a great experience?
In the end it's hard to find causality here. Those are more or less two sides of the same coin. I guess the question is how much need there is on either side for punishments to keep the dynamic going. In our specific case, we clearly provided the evidence that neither of us needed it.